The President’s support base, and indeed the vast majority of Irish people, cherish our neutrality and oppose war. The government’s decision to force through this momentous change in foreign policy without consulting the people – despite polls repeatedly showing the public’s desire to remain neutral – is a profound democratic failure. Even an initial Citizen’s Assembly was never organised, clearly because its outcome would have been against abandoning our neutrality.
This is the crucial context President Connolly must consider. A referendum was rejected on the spurious grounds that the Oireachtas was “democracy in operation.” This is a fallacious argument, and the very existence of the Triple Lock proves it. The three locks – Cabinet, Parliament, and the UN – are a testament to the Irish state’s acknowledgment of the people’s distrust of the ruling parties controlled Dáil and Cabinet on matters of neutrality and militarisation. The third lock, the UN, is a solemn promise, formally expressed in the Seville Declaration by previous Fianna Fáil governments, not to leave Irish neutrality in the hands of our politicians. The current government’s act is a duplicitous attempt to disenfranchise the Irish people.
As Supreme Commander of the Irish Defence Forces, the President must also weigh the grave consequences of this legislation. This is not only an undermining of Irish democracy but a reckless policy that will cause the deaths of our troops. The Minister of Defence’s announcement that Irish troops will return to Southern Lebanon is a prime example. After over 40 years as peacekeepers, they will be sent back as peace enforcers – a euphemism for waging illegal wars. Their task will be to attack and disarm the defenders of Lebanon, Hezbollah, an outrage that is counter to UN resolutions and places us on the side of a genocidal axis.
To put it bluntly, the signing of this new Defence Act into law will be signing the death warrants of many of our troops, not just in Lebanon, but in whatever military adventure the government decides. This contravenes Article 29 of Bunreacht na hÉireann. On that basis alone, it should be opposed. Article 29.1: Ireland affirms its devotion to the ideal of peace and friendly co-operation amongst nations founded on international justice and morality.Article 29.2: Ireland affirms its adherence to the principle of the pacific settlement of international disputes by international arbitration or judicial determination.
In other words, we are abandoning our anti-colonial past to join with the Empire. This is on a par with John Redmond’s call for Irishmen to fight in World War I. Then as now, Irish soldiers will be dying for a genocidal empire. Historically, we see the very foundation of the Irish state stems from opposition to Redmond’s treachery. Today, we still view the Easter Rising of 1916 as the foundation stone of the Irish Republic. And yet, our government refuses to give us a referendum.
Given the gravity of the situation and the clear danger to Irish lives and democracy, we hope President Connolly refuses to sign this bill, irrespective of the Supreme Court’s findings.
Galway Alliance Against War is an anti-war and peace activist group based in Galway, Ireland. It opposes war, military imperialism, and nuclear or arms proliferation through education, advocacy, and protest.


